Before Metal Urges was born, Brutal Truth was one of the first bands we talked about covering, and it just so happens that bassist/vocalist Danny Lilker announced last year that Brutal Truth, the band that he founded in 1990, is disbanding on Oct. 18 of this year, which was his 50th birthday. In a prepared statement, he remarked that he is “retiring from being a full-time recording and touring musician.” So this is a tribute to his longest-running band—long live Brutal Truth!
“P.S.P.I.,” “Birth of Ignorance,” “Collateral Damage,” “Walking Corpse,” and “Time,” from Extreme Conditions Demand Extreme Responses (1992, Earache)
BT was formed when Anthrax bassist Danny Lilker left thrash band Nuclear Assault. Their more-death-than-grind debut on Earache is one of our favorite metal debuts of all time. “Collateral Damage” holds a Guinness Book world record for the shortest video: 2 seconds long with 48 still photos displayed in rapid succession, ending with an explosion. “Walking Corpse” was later re-recorded in 2011 for a Decibel Magazine flexi.
“Black Door Mine,” “Godplayer,” “Ordinary Madness,” and “Choice of a New Generation,” from Need to Control (1994, Earache)
This was the mindblowing sophomore album from these soon-to-be grind freaks. Original drummer Scott Lewis was replaced by Ninefinger’s Rich Hoak, who has been their drummer ever since. Hoak changed the band’s output with his grind drumming style, whereas Lewis was more of a death-metal drummer. NTC had less death metal and more grind this time, yet it was hailed as their most progressive and experimental material. This is the band’s definitive album, though its music is not indicative of the majority of their output.
“Blind Leading the Blind,” “Pass Some Down,” and “Hypocrite Invasion,” from Kill Trend Suicide (1996, Relapse)
The band split from Earache because of ongoing frustrations with the label and joined Relapse, which certainly boosted their status as the premier grindcore label. BT would stay on Relapse for the rest of their career. KTS was a definite musical shift for the band: no more death-metal leanings, just straight-up grind, some slow, some fast: 10 songs on a mini-album. The cover art was photographed in the old Lancaster apartment of Pellet and Jeff Wagner, then publicists at Relapse.
“Jemenez Cricket,” “Callous,” and “Pork Farm,” from Sounds of the Animal Kingdom (1997, Relapse)
This album was a rapid follow-up to the very short KTS with much of the same grind. The cover art shows a half-man, half-ape—one of the coolest metal covers at the time. The model was actually Relapse’s UPS delivery man, and after the photo shoot they gave him a case of beer in payment!
“Sugar Daddy,” “Branded,” and “Humpty Finance,” from Evolution Through Revolution (2009, Relapse)
The band had broken up in 1998 and released a swansong compilation of odds-and-sods, 1999’s Goodbye Cruel World. During this hiatus, BT members kept themselves busy in other bands: vocalist Kevin Sharp joined Australian death/grinders Damaged for 2000’s Purified in Pain on Rotten Records. Before and during BT, Lilker played in the bands Anthrax, Exit-13, Nuclear Assault, Hemlock, The Ravenous, Stormtroopers of Death, Malformed Earthborn (Shane Embury’s noise band with former BT drummer Scott Lewis on their sole release, 1995’s Defiance of the Ugly by the Merely Repulsive), et al. After BT, Lilker starred in a reformed Nuclear Assault, Venomous Concept (with Sharp plus Danny Herrera and Shane Embury of Napalm Death). Hoak heads up his own grind band Total F**king Destruction and founded Deaf American Records. Longtime guitarist Brent “Gurn” McCarty didn’t return for this reunion; instead, Lethargy guitarist Eric Burke joined the ranks. ETR is much more grind-based than their other recordings, almost to the point of redundancy.
“Simple Math,” “Malice,” “Swift and Violent (Swift Version),” and “Trash,” End Time (2011, Relapse)
End Time sounds like much of the same from ETR: very grindy, very fast, better production.
“The Stroy,” The Axiom of Post Inhumanity (2013, Relapse)
BT’s swan song is a split release with powerviolence noisemongers Bastard Noise from California. Bastard Noise have over 100 releases since the ’90s, so we’re sure BT were excited to do a split release with them. It’s fitting that their final (?) recording is noise, so our outro for this episode is a noise track similar to our episode intro: the noise track #1 from their debut album.
The Future of Brutal Truth?
Sharp is now in Primate (with Bill Kelliher of Mastodon), Lock Up (with Tomas Lindberg of At the Gates and Shane Embury of Napalm Death) and writes a monthly column for Decibel. Lilker is back in Nuclear Assault and is working on a new album for release in 2015; he adds, “I will still have creative output with my 2 local bands in Rochester NY, Nokturnal Hellstorm and Blurring and do the occasional project tour, but as of mid-October, Brutal Truth will no longer exist.” Hoak continues to have amazing drum faces in TFD and his ambient band Peacemaker.